לילה טוב אורח/ת
עכשיו בכלוב

In the Pink

סוטה, חמודה, ובלונדינית ברמות. ראו הוזהרתם. 8-)

================================================================
"But if you love and must needs have desires, let these be your desires
To melt and be like a running brook that sings its melody to the night"
Khalil Gibran

It was beautiful to live"
when you lived!
The world is bluer and of the earth
at night, when I sleep
enormous, within your small hands."

Pablo Neruda
לפני 14 שנים. 23 בדצמבר 2009 בשעה 19:48


Am I being over-sensitive?

Or would you hate it if someone accused you of trying to claim that the Holocaust was the fault of the Jews?

Yeah, I thought so.

I did something ill-thought-out this week.

I took a post of mine, this one, and put it up on Fetlife in the Rants group. It seemed like a good idea at the time, but I had forgotten that it had originally been written from a very personal point of view, as a result of something specific happening -- for an audience of people who come to my blog to read the nonsense that I specifically write.

The reaction was not what I expected it to be, which will just teach me to re-use a post, lazy pink tabby that I am. Most people reading it did not get it, and commented accordingly. Unlike those who read it here, the majority of whom *did* get it, having been witness to the events that precipitated the piece in the first place.

Now, please understand -- I am not a shy and retiring wallflower. I'm always happy to receive and accept criticism. I believe I can hold my own in discussion, I will acede to points that are correct, despite my fervently wishing that they weren't, and I will passionately defend points of view that I believe to be correct, or that are my own truth. I don't need people to fight my battles for me, and I'm not scared of dealing with things.

Not any more, anyhow.

There are also times when I will not engage with a person, when I feel that to do so will give their pathetic and ridiculous argument legs.

Such a thing happened to me today.

To this second-hand rant, I received a personal comment, sent to me by private messagewhich said that in my sentence "I'm a proud Jew, but karma's a bitch", I was in fact implying that all the blame of the holocaust lay at the feet of the Jewish people.

I was so upset, I immediately blocked the person who wrote to me -- and on Fetlife, that also means deleting the correspondence that has happened up until that moment. I therefore have no proof of what happened -- although god knows I don't need any.

Another of my less fine hours.

My meaning behind that particular sentence had been a play on the fact that karma was a concept of Hindu origin, and that I am a Jew.

I therefore ask the question -- where the fuck does the Holocaust come into it? It makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.

Am I being too sensitive? How would you feel if that or a similar accusation were levelled at you?

The question is mildly hypothetical. What's done is done. The rant is still up and I'm not even trying to have it pulled, although I freely concede that re-posting the piece there as a rant was not my most intelligent decision.

I just needed to write about it.

Thanks for listening.

astaro - people will see what they want to see. he is either a racist and made that connection all by himself or he is just incredibly ignorant and knows nothing about Jews other then holocaust and us crucifying Jesus. either way, not the brightest of peas..
לפני 14 שנים
LillyVonSchtupp​(מתחלפת){Dan_Kap} - Well, quite.

A couple of nipple clamps short of a session, you might say.

:-)
לפני 14 שנים
בלוסום​(לא בעסק) - א. WTF? איפה הקשר בין מה שכתבת לשואה? זה הקשר
שנעשה אך ורק על ידי מי שעשה אותו.

ב. מסכימה עם החתול בפוסט המקורי... :-) what a
bitchslap, totaly wasted on the target....

לפני 14 שנים
LillyVonSchtupp​(מתחלפת){Dan_Kap} - "זה הקשר שנעשה אך ורק על ידי מי שעשה אותו."

צודקת ב-100%.

והחתול, כפי שאומרים באנגלית, really knows his onions.

:-D
לפני 14 שנים
בלוסום​(לא בעסק) - וול! למדתי פתגם חדש :)
לפני 14 שנים
LillyVonSchtupp​(מתחלפת){Dan_Kap} - Heh, stick around, they just get better and more prolific.

:-)
לפני 14 שנים
בלוסום​(לא בעסק) - מה זה PROLIFIC?
לפני 14 שנים
פעם פרח​(נשלטת) - ok, first things first

maybe it's the late hour but I don't really understand how does being a Jew, or a proud Jew,
has something to do with "Respect The Kink That Is Not Yours"

Is it the idea of "respect my religion and I'll respect yours ?"

I'm not getting the direct correlation between the two.

And as for the holocaust reference...
I guess that for a a lot of people the Jew issue always connect to the holocaust.

And I guess that someone who doesn't know you,
or the way you think, or write,
will make the connection that
"I'm a proud Jew, but karma's a bitch"
means that
"Jews got what they deserved"

sort of a twisted logic

thank you, you make me practice my English :-)
לפני 14 שנים
LillyVonSchtupp​(מתחלפת){Dan_Kap} - No.

As I explained, i was saying that while I am Jewish I subscribe to the vaguely Hindu notion of Karma -- or, in other words, what goes around, comes around.

To then further apply this in more specific terms, regarding the original subject matter in the original post -- "you sit there in judgment over something you do not understand, or hold all the facts that apply -- watch how this comes back to bite you in the arse."

See?
לפני 14 שנים
פעם פרח​(נשלטת) - yeah, it makes perfect sense when you explain it that way
I'm guessing it also makes perfect sense for people who know you and the way you think and write

but others might understand differently

I consider myself a person with somewhat logical thinking
and until now, I didn't completly get the Jew reference in your original post.

I didn't give it my own interpertation,
but I'm not surprised that other people who read you did read it as something else

because I think your point in the Jew reference was a little unclear
and it such case, some people will give it a different meaning
לפני 14 שנים
LillyVonSchtupp​(מתחלפת){Dan_Kap} - You're right. Quite right. Like I said, I understand that now, as I bask in the glow of retrospect -- which is always 20:20.

However, the reaction when I explained the expression was to make the accusation I mentioned in this post. Not before.

Le sigh....
לפני 14 שנים
פעם פרח​(נשלטת) - oh well
don't take to heart and don't inhale :-)
לפני 14 שנים

להוספת תגובה לבלוג זה עליך להיות חבר/ה רשומ/ה ומחובר/ת לאתר


הרשמ/י התחבר/י